Leveraging simulation to provide a practical framework for estimating the novel scope of risk of large language models in healthcare.

BACKGROUND: Large language models (LLMs) are rapidly entering clinical and consumer use, yet their probabilistic outputs have delivered a variety of unsafe user responses. Difficulties in quantifying and mitigating risks posed by LLMs threaten to stall regulatory evaluation and clinical deployment of LLM-based software as a medical device (LLM-SaMD). Practical approaches are needed to extend existing medical-device regulations to LLM-SaMDs. OBJECTIVE: To demonstrate how simulation can extend existing medical-device risk management frameworks for addressing LLM-SaMD-specific risks. METHODS: We implement a simulation-based methodology for estimating LLM-SaMD risk. Fourteen open-source models were evaluated on three safety-classification tasks: suicidal-ideation, therapy-request and therapy-like interaction detection. Synthetic datasets were generated by Gemini 2.5 Pro and evaluated by psychiatrists. Model false-negative rates informed estimates of P 1, the likelihood that a hazard progresses to a hazardous situation, and P 2, the likelihood that that situation results in harm. FINDINGS: LLM success at generating synthetic datasets varied by task, with strong performance for neutral and non-therapeutic content but frequent errors in suicidal-ideation and therapy-like interactions. Performance generally improved with model size. Estimated P 1 values ranged from 1.1×10⁻⁸ to 1.6×10⁻⁴ and P 2 from 4.9×10⁻⁵ to 5.1×10⁻³, spanning four orders of magnitude. CONCLUSIONS: By linking model failure modes to structured pathways to harm, simulation can extend existing medical-device risk frameworks to help address the probabilistic and context-dependent risks of LLM-SaMDs. CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS: Simulation-based risk estimation offers a practical way to characterise the risk landscape for specific LLM-SaMD, patient population and clinical context combinations.

Preparing paper insights from the available abstract and paper details.

Authors

Kalinich M; Luccarelli J; Santa Maria J Jr; Moss F; Torous J

Published

Jan 1, 2026

Journal or venue

BMJ mental health

DOI

10.1136/bmjment-2026-302626

Paper type

journal article

Source

Pubmed