Simon Allzén · 2026
Paper
The scientific discovery of dark matter has been pursued in two very different methodological and epistemic contexts. A microphysical context centered around the laboratory detection of a new particle, and a macrophysical context based on the astronomical identification of a non-luminous gravitating component. The justification for the salience of methodological diversity is that these different methods are complementary ways to discovering aspects of the same entity. The weakly interacting massive particle (WIMP) made this expectation scientifically credible by connecting a particle candidate to a cosmological abundance, experimental searches, and explanations of astronomical phenomena. What happens to this connection when the WIMP loses its central position? I analyze 201,627 NASA Astrophysics Data System records to examine the organization of research following the decline of WIMP prominence. Astrophysics and high-energy physics remain jointly dominant, while WIMP-related mentions decline in both fields and successor candidates receive different degrees of attention. Concept networks show that WIMP-related research remains central across the literature, even as cross-field connections become less concentrated around it. These indicators measure research attention; they do not establish what scientists would accept as a discovery. I interpret the findings through a framework distinguishing constitutive identification, cosmic attribution, explanatory adequacy, and the cross-domain identification needed to connect them. A particle, compact-object population, or gravitational theory can resolve different parts of the inherited problem, and a partial or multicomponent discovery can leave other parts open. 'Diverging paths' describes this branching of possible resolutions.
Analysis
Preparing paper insights from the available abstract and paper details.
Discovery
Long-Yue Li; Li-Ming Cao; Yungui Gong; Xia-Yuan Liu; Liang-Bi Wu; Wenting Zhou
B. I. Ciocan; N. F. Bouché; J. Fensch; D. Krajnović; J. Freundlich; H. Desmond; A. Jeanneau; B. Famaey
F. Acerbi; P. Adhikari; P. Agnes; I. Ahmad; S. Albergo; I. F. Albuquerque; T. Alexander; A. K. Alton; P. Amaudruz; G. A. Anastasi; M. Angiolilli; E. Aprile; D. J. Auty; M. Ave Pernas; O. Azzolini; H. O. Back; Z. Balmforth; A. Barrado Olmedo; P. Barrillon; G. Batignani; S. Bharat; P. Bhowmick; S. Blua; V. Bocci; W. Bonivento; B. Bottino; M. G. Boulay; T. Braun; A. Buchowicz; J. Busto; M. Cadeddu; M. Cadoni; R. Calabrese; V. I. Calì; A. Caminata; N. Canci; M. Caravati; M. Cardenas-Montes; N. Cargioli; M. Carlini; L. Castellani; P. Castello; D. F. F. S. Cavalcante; P. Cavalcante; S. Cebrian; A. Chepurnov; L. Cifarelli; Y. Coadou; I. Coarasa; V. Cocco; E. Conde Vilda; L. Consiglio; H. Coombes; A. F. V. Cortez; B. S. Costa; P. A. Costa e Silva; M. Czubak; S. D'Auria; M. D. Da Rocha Rolo; A. Dainty; G. Darbo; S. Davini; R. de Asmundis; S. De Cecco; M. De Napoli; G. Dellacasa; A. Derbin; L. Di Noto; P. Di Stefano; D. Díaz Mairena; C. Dionisi; G. Dolganov; F. Dordei; A. Elersich; E. Ellingwood; T. Erjavec; N. Fearon; M. Fernandez Diaz; L. Ferro; A. Ficorella; G. Fiorillo; D. Fleming; L. Flores; P. Franchini; D. Franco; H. Frandini Gatti; F. Gabriele; D. Gahan; C. Galbiati; G. Galiński; G. Gallina; M. Garbini; P. Garcia Abia; A. Gawdzik; G. K. Giovanetti; A. Gola; L. Grandi; G. Grauso; G. Grilli di Cortona; A. Grobov; M. Gromov; J. Guerrero Cánovas; M. Gulino; S. B. Habtemariam; B. R. Hackett; A. Hallin; M. Haranczyk; T. Hessel; C. Hidalgo; J. Hollingham; S. Horikawa; J. Hu; F. Hubaut; D. Huff; T. Hugues; A. Ianni; A. Ianni; V. Ippolito; A. Jamil; C. Jillings; P. Kachru; R. Keloth; N. Kemmerich; A. Kemp; K. Kondo; G. Korga; L. Kotsiopoulou; S. Koulosousas; P. Kunze; M. Kuss; M. Kuźniak; M. Kuzwa; M. I. Kwon; M. La Commara; M. Lai; E. Le Guirriec; E. Leason; A. Leoni; L. Lidey; J. D. Lipp; L. Lippolis; M. Lissia; L. Luzzi; O. Lychagina; O. Macfadyen; J. Machts; I. Machulin; S. Mameli; S. Manecki; I. Manthos; A. Marasciulli; S. M. Mari; C. Mariani; J. Maricic; M. Martinez; G. Matteucci; K. Mavrokoridis; A. Mazzi; A. B. McDonald; L. Meng; A. Messina; R. Milincic; G. Miller; S. Minutoli; A. Mitra; J. Monroe; M. Morrocchi; A. Morsy; V. Muratova; M. Murra; C. Muscas; P. Musico; R. Nania; M. Nessi; G. Nieradka; K. Nikolopoulos; E. Nikoloudaki; J. Nowak; K. Olchanski; A. Oleinik; P. Organtini; A. Ortiz de Solórzano; A. Padmanabhan; M. Pallavicini; L. Pandola; E. Pantic; E. Paoloni; D. Papi; L. Parellada Monreal; B. Park; G. Pastuszak; G. Paternoster; R. Pavarani; A. Peck; P. A. Pegoraro; K. Pelczar; R. Perez; V. Pesudo; S. Piacentini; N. Pino; G. Plante; A. Pocar; S. Pordes; P. Pralavorio; E. Preosti; D. Price; G. Prior; M. Pronesti; S. Puglia; M. Queiroga Bazetto; F. Raffaelli; F. Ragusa; Y. Ramachers; A. Ramirez; S. Ravinthiran; K. Raymond; M. Razeti; A. L. Renshaw; A. Repond; M. Rescigno; S. Resconi; F. Retiere; A. Ritchie-Yates; A. Rivetti; A. Roberts; C. Roberts; D. Rodríguez Rodas; G. Rogers; L. Romero; M. Rossi; D. Rudik; J. Runge; M. Sabia; C. Salerno; P. Salomone; O. Samoylov; S. Sanfilippo; D. Santone; R. Santorelli; E. M. Santos; I. Sargeant; M. L. Sarsa; C. Savarese; E. Scapparone; D. Semenov; C. Seoane; A. Serrecchia; M. Sestu; V. Shalamova; S. Sharma Poudel; A. Sheshukov; M. Simeone; D. Sitzia; P. Skensved; M. Skorokhvatov; O. Smirnov; T. Smirnova; B. Smith; F. Spadoni; M. Spangenberg; A. Steri; M. R. Stock; V. Stornelli; S. Stracka; A. Sung; C. Sunny; Y. Suvorov; A. M. Szelc; O. Taborda; B. Tam; R. Tartaglia; A. Taylor; J. Taylor; G. Testera; A. Thompson; S. Torres-Lara; A. Tricomi; S. Tullio; E. Unzhakov; M. Van Uffelen; P. Ventura; G. Vera Díaz; S. Viel; A. Vishneva; R. B. Vogelaar; J. Vossebeld; B. Vyas; M. Wada; M. Walczak; Y. Wang; S. Westerdale; L. Williams; M. M. Wojcik; M. Wojcik; Z. Xu; J. Yin; A. Zabihi; P. Zakhary; A. Zani; H. Zhan; Y. Zhang; G. Zuzel
Robin Anthony-Petersen; Orion Ning; Yu Watanabe; Benjamin R. Safdi; Maíra Dutra; Francesca Calore; Savitri Gallego; William Guan; Christopher M. Karwin; Alexander Kusenko; Israel Martinez-Castellanos; Shigeki Matsumoto; Michela Negro; Uwe Oberlack; Field R. Rogers; Thomas Siegert; Tadayuki Takahashi; Haoyu Xie; Hiroki Yoneda; Andreas Zoglauer; Steven E. Boggs; Dieter H. Hartmann; Carolyn A. Kierans; John A. Tomsick
Pinku Routaray; Rudra N. Sahoo; Bharat Kuma; M. Bhuyan
Payaswinee Arvikar; Prashant Thakur; Sarmistha Banik
Source record