Peter M. Higgins; Weibin Chen; Oliver Warr; Lucas M. Fifer; Wanying Kang; Charles S. Cockell; Barbara Sherwood Lollar · 2026
Paper
Ocean worlds are considered as targets for life detection missions because they meet several key requirements for habitability. However, identifying potential life on other worlds requires observing clear and unambiguous biosignature signals above the existing abiotic baseline. Consequently, this necessitates evaluating uncertainty and variability in the abiotic baseline, including processes that can overlap, attenuate, or obfuscate biosignatures before they are observed. This article develops a quantitative framework for holistically evaluating abiotic baselines on ocean worlds to guide life detection strategies. Using Enceladus as an example, we assess the potential of using: i) CH$_{4}$ isotopes and their relationship with CO$_{2}$, and ii) amino acid chirality as biosignatures, demonstrating that uncertainties in abiotic processes currently prevent hypothetical future $δ^{13}$C$_{\mathrm{CO2}}$ and $δ^{13}$C$_{\mathrm{CH4}}$ measurements from definitively inferring a biosphere on Enceladus. Additionally, our results quantitatively show that neglecting the abiotic baseline risks false negative life detection claims for both isotopic and chiral biosignatures. Interpreting these and other alternative biosignatures on Enceladus, Europa, Titan, and similar planetary bodies therefore requires complimentary geophysical observations such as constraining internal temperatures to within $\sim$10-100$^{\circ}$C, and improving characterisation of the target's rheology, lithology, initial abiotic organic inventory and ocean transport timescales.
Analysis
This paper proposes a quantitative framework to evaluate abiotic baselines on ocean worlds, crucial for distinguishing biosignatures from non-biological processes in the search for extraterrestrial life.
Discovery
Bastien Bodin; Daniel Cordier; Ashley Gerard Davies
Kurt D. Retherford; Philippa M. Molyneux; Thomas K. Greathouse; Michael W. Davis; G. Randall Gladstone; Steven C. Persyn; Maarten H. Versteeg; Mary F. Araujo; Fran Bagenal; Tracy M. Becker; Arnaud Beth; Ronald K. Black; Bertrand Bonfond; Shawn M. Brooks; Emma J. Bunce; Alain Carapelle; Steven Cortinas; Gregory J. Dirks; Bryan Esquivel; Paul D. Feldman; Sue Ferrell; Mark Ferris; Leigh N. Fletcher; Matthew A. Freeman; Marina Galand; Rohini S. Giles; Denis Grodent; Vincent Hue; Erica Johnson; Joshua A. Kammer; Cynthia Kempe; Laurent Lamy; Adrian Martin; Melissa A. McGrath; Edward G. Nerney; Carlos Nuñez; Zachary Olsen; Norman Pelletier; Brandon Perez; Kristian B. Persson; Eric Quémerais; Rick Raffanti; Ujjwal Raut; Ryan Rickerson; Lorenz Roth; Oswald H. W. Siegmund; John R. Spencer; Andrew J. Steffl; Bradley J. Trantham; John V. Vallerga; Todd J. Veach; Michael A. Velez; Brandon C. Walther; the JUICE-UVS Team
Nancy Y. Kiang; Christopher Gisriel; Robert E. Blankenship; Mary N. Parenteau; Hazel A. Barton; Oded Béjà; Anthony J. Burnetti; Ligia F. Coelho; Saleheh Ebadirad; Nathan M. Ennist; Yuka Fujii; Colin Gates; R. J. Graham; Keiichi Inoue; Betül Kaçar; Yu Komatsu; Émilie A. Laflèche; Nicoletta La Rocca; Elisabetta Liistro; Jonathan Lindsey; Timothy Lyons; Carolina A. Martinez-Gutierrez; Taro Matsuo; Victoria Meadows; Gary F. Moore; Massimo Olivucci; Kevin E. Redding; Edward W. Schwieterman; Tejinder Singh; Kenji Takizawa; Anna Grace Ulses; Junko Yano; Felisa Wolfe-Simon; Michael L. Wong; Anastasia G. Yanchilina
Aaron McKinnon; Neveda Naz
Caroline Haslebacher; Emeline Bolmont; Marco Cilibrasi; Jonathan Grone; Nico Haslebacher; Ravit Helled; Mathilde Kervazo; Niels F. W. Ligterink; Christophe Lovis; Lucio Mayer; Lorenzo Obersnel; Rafael Ottersberg; Apurva V. Oza; C. H. Lucas Patty; Antoine Pommerol; Ganna Portyankina; Alyssa R. Rhoden; Leander Schlarmann; Yuhito Shibaike; Vishaal Singh; Audrey H. Vorburger; Peter Wurz
Conor A. Nixon; Samuel Birch; Audrey Chatain; Charles Cockell; Kendra K. Farnsworth; Peter M. Higgins; Stéphane Le Mouélic; Rosaly M. C. Lopes; Michael J. Malaska; Mohit Melwani Daswani; Kelly E. Miller; Catherine D. Neish; Olaf G. Podlaha; Jani Radebaugh; Lauren R. Schurmeier; Ashley Schoenfeld; Krista M. Soderlund; Anezina Solomonidou; Christophe Sotin; Nicholas A. Teanby; Tetsuya Tokano; Steven D. Vance
Source record