Sam Nasreldine; Antonin Affholder; Laura Molares Moncayo; Régis Ferrière; François Guyot · 2026
Paper
Saturn's icy moon Enceladus is a prime target in the search for life beyond Earth. Abundant H2 and CH4 in Enceladus's south-polar plume have been shown to be consistent with hydrogenotrophic methanogens feeding on products of long-lived serpentinization. However, thermo-permeability models make sustained core-wide H2 production by serpentinization uncertain. We therefore explore whether an alternative metabolism based on fermentation-driven heterotrophy could reproduce Cassini H2 and CH4 escape fluxes under limited serpentinization. We develop a coupled ecosystem model of fermentation and methanogenesis in a hydrothermal-ocean-plume framework, using glycine as a proxy for amino-acid-like fermentable organics. With effectively no abiotic H2 and CH4 input, purely heterotrophic communities with fermenters and methanogens can reproduce both Cassini-derived flux intervals given sufficient hydrothermal glycine-equivalent supply, while the estimated organic stock could sustain the required H2 production on gigayear timescales if fully available. We then test a scenario with input ranges for fermentable organic matter, H2, and CH4 informed by asteroid-sample measurements and geochemical estimates of limited serpentinization. Simulations within both Cassini-derived flux intervals are concentrated in communities with acetoclastic methanogens; Bayesian model comparison favors the same communities. This holds even allowing for greater abiotic H2 and CH4 inputs that reduce the fermentable-organic supply required to reproduce the plume. We therefore identify fermentation heterotrophy as a testable alternative to purely hydrogenotrophic, serpentinization-dominated biotic interpretations and motivate future plume searches for co-exported fermentation products, including acetate and ammonium, together with measurements of methane carbon isotopes.
Analysis
Preparing paper insights from the available abstract and paper details.
Discovery
Bastien Bodin; Daniel Cordier; Ashley Gerard Davies
Kurt D. Retherford; Philippa M. Molyneux; Thomas K. Greathouse; Michael W. Davis; G. Randall Gladstone; Steven C. Persyn; Maarten H. Versteeg; Mary F. Araujo; Fran Bagenal; Tracy M. Becker; Arnaud Beth; Ronald K. Black; Bertrand Bonfond; Shawn M. Brooks; Emma J. Bunce; Alain Carapelle; Steven Cortinas; Gregory J. Dirks; Bryan Esquivel; Paul D. Feldman; Sue Ferrell; Mark Ferris; Leigh N. Fletcher; Matthew A. Freeman; Marina Galand; Rohini S. Giles; Denis Grodent; Vincent Hue; Erica Johnson; Joshua A. Kammer; Cynthia Kempe; Laurent Lamy; Adrian Martin; Melissa A. McGrath; Edward G. Nerney; Carlos Nuñez; Zachary Olsen; Norman Pelletier; Brandon Perez; Kristian B. Persson; Eric Quémerais; Rick Raffanti; Ujjwal Raut; Ryan Rickerson; Lorenz Roth; Oswald H. W. Siegmund; John R. Spencer; Andrew J. Steffl; Bradley J. Trantham; John V. Vallerga; Todd J. Veach; Michael A. Velez; Brandon C. Walther; the JUICE-UVS Team
Nancy Y. Kiang; Christopher Gisriel; Robert E. Blankenship; Mary N. Parenteau; Hazel A. Barton; Oded Béjà; Anthony J. Burnetti; Ligia F. Coelho; Saleheh Ebadirad; Nathan M. Ennist; Yuka Fujii; Colin Gates; R. J. Graham; Keiichi Inoue; Betül Kaçar; Yu Komatsu; Émilie A. Laflèche; Nicoletta La Rocca; Elisabetta Liistro; Jonathan Lindsey; Timothy Lyons; Carolina A. Martinez-Gutierrez; Taro Matsuo; Victoria Meadows; Gary F. Moore; Massimo Olivucci; Kevin E. Redding; Edward W. Schwieterman; Tejinder Singh; Kenji Takizawa; Anna Grace Ulses; Junko Yano; Felisa Wolfe-Simon; Michael L. Wong; Anastasia G. Yanchilina
Aaron McKinnon; Neveda Naz
Peter M. Higgins; Weibin Chen; Oliver Warr; Lucas M. Fifer; Wanying Kang; Charles S. Cockell; Barbara Sherwood Lollar
Caroline Haslebacher; Emeline Bolmont; Marco Cilibrasi; Jonathan Grone; Nico Haslebacher; Ravit Helled; Mathilde Kervazo; Niels F. W. Ligterink; Christophe Lovis; Lucio Mayer; Lorenzo Obersnel; Rafael Ottersberg; Apurva V. Oza; C. H. Lucas Patty; Antoine Pommerol; Ganna Portyankina; Alyssa R. Rhoden; Leander Schlarmann; Yuhito Shibaike; Vishaal Singh; Audrey H. Vorburger; Peter Wurz
Source record